So I know there are a few guys here with chopped tops, and I'm a couple months away from cutting the roof off of mine (gutting the XJ and gathering parts right now), but now I'm starting to run into a bit of a dilemma. How far is too far?
My original plan was to cut from the A-pillar straight back. This would involve getting rid of the entire B-pillar too.
Then this weekend I was doing some more homework on this, and I saw pictures of chops that left the A- and B-pillars and the roof over the front seats, with the chop starting just behind the backseats.
Regardless of what I do, there will be a cage protecting the front seats all the way through the rear of the rig. My question is: is there a significant PLUS to leaving the A- and B-pillars in place? Structurally, if I'm replacing both with tube, then the strength should be at a minimum equal to what was there originally.
Let's sound off on this, I need to get this hammered out...
Original idea would look like this:
Thoughts? Opinions? (Looking for both structural and aesthetic opinions!)
My original plan was to cut from the A-pillar straight back. This would involve getting rid of the entire B-pillar too.
Then this weekend I was doing some more homework on this, and I saw pictures of chops that left the A- and B-pillars and the roof over the front seats, with the chop starting just behind the backseats.
Regardless of what I do, there will be a cage protecting the front seats all the way through the rear of the rig. My question is: is there a significant PLUS to leaving the A- and B-pillars in place? Structurally, if I'm replacing both with tube, then the strength should be at a minimum equal to what was there originally.
Let's sound off on this, I need to get this hammered out...
Original idea would look like this:

Thoughts? Opinions? (Looking for both structural and aesthetic opinions!)